The Short Answer
If you're moving from Chicago to Florida with about $2 million, the property tax bill on a new purchase in Fort Lauderdale or Boca Raton lands in the same neighborhood as a city of Chicago bill. The real savings is Illinois' 4.95% income tax, which goes to zero once you're a Florida resident, plus no state estate tax. Insurance gives some of that back, so run the whole stack, not just the tax rate. Talk to your CPA before you list in Chicago or file a Florida homestead.
What the Same Budget Buys
Chicago families usually tell me, "My property taxes are brutal, so Florida must be cheaper." Here's how I'd run it with my own money, using one illustrative $2 million home in three places.
September 2026 medians, from Realtor association data:
- City of Chicago: $389,900 for all property types, and $375,000 for single-family homes (Illinois REALTORS)
- Fort Lauderdale: $705,000, single-family (MIAMI REALTORS + RWorld, city report)
- Boca Raton: $1.25 million, single-family (same report)
$2 million is a top-of-market budget in Chicago, about five times the city's single-family median. In South Florida it's a strong budget, but the high end is deep. Million-dollar homes made up 29% of Palm Beach County sales and 21% of Broward sales in that report, versus under 10% nationally. Waterfront eats the budget fast.
In Coral Ridge, the Q3 2026 zip medians were $1.37 million to $1.79 million, so $2 million is a real single-family budget and often gets you a canal lot and a dock. In Boca, the citywide single-family median was $1.25 million, but east Boca is a spread: some streets fit $2 million, and the walk-to-Mizner or true waterfront blocks run higher. Compared with Lincoln Park or the North Shore, that same $2 million usually buys more house, and a dock, in Coral Ridge or on the right east Boca street. Up there you're paying for the city lot, not ocean access.
Property Tax: Closer Than You Think
Cook County. Residential property is generally assessed at 10% of market value, times the state equalizer (3.0300 for 2025), minus the $10,000 Homeowner Exemption, times your composite rate. The Cook County Clerk's 2025 report puts the average Chicago rate at 6.853%. Wilmette (6.357%) was the lowest suburban average; the South and West suburbs averaged 11.862%. On a $2 million Chicago home valued at $2 million by the Assessor, that's roughly $40,800 a year. In Wilmette, about $37,900.
Fort Lauderdale. The 2026 final millage for most of the city (code 0312) is 18.4026 mills ($18.40 per $1,000 of taxable value), per the Broward County Property Appraiser. School mills are 6.4527 and non-school mills are 11.9499. The city adds stormwater and fire assessments, $451 and $444 for single-family homes in FY 2027.
Boca Raton. The city's own 2026 brochure lists 16.9090 total mills for property inside city limits, including 6.2870 school mills. Some Boca parcels sit in additional districts, so confirm the bill on the specific property.
Homestead. If it's your permanent residence on January 1, Florida takes $25,000 off school taxes. An additional exemption, adjusted for inflation, comes off non-school taxes ($26,411 in 2026). After year one, Save Our Homes caps assessed value increases at 3% or CPI, whichever is lower. That cap is where Florida pulls ahead over time.
Run the math on a homesteaded $2 million home, assuming the property appraiser's just value equals the price: about $36,000 in Fort Lauderdale plus city fees, and about $33,100 in Boca. Those are illustrations, not a tax bill. Your CPA and the county property appraiser should review the actual parcel.
Where Amendment 3 fits
Florida voters approved Amendment 3 on November 3 with about 62% (certified by the state on November 17). Residents by December 31, 2026 get up to $150,000 off non-school taxes in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028. Most Chicago families I talk to arrive in 2027 or later. You start at the existing exemption and get the bigger one from your fifth year of exemption, subject to any court challenge. At Fort Lauderdale's non-school rate, a $200,000 exemption gap is about $2,400 a year. I covered the details in my Amendment 3 results post.
Income Tax: The Real Swing
Illinois taxes individual net income at a flat 4.95%, per the Illinois Department of Revenue. Florida has no personal income tax, per the Florida Department of Revenue.
On $500,000 of Illinois net income, that's $24,750 a year. On $1 million, $49,500. Every year.
One catch on the way out. Illinois allocates a nonresident's gain on Illinois real estate to Illinois (Schedule NR instructions). If your Chicago gain beats the federal home-sale exclusion ($250,000 single, $500,000 married filing jointly), Illinois can tax the excess even after you move. Talk to your CPA before you list, and again before you change residency.
Estate Tax: Quiet but Big
Illinois' estate tax exclusion is $4 million, and the Illinois Attorney General notes it isn't portable to a surviving spouse. The AG's example: a $5 million all-Illinois estate owes $285,714 in Illinois estate tax and nothing federally (the 2026 federal exclusion is $15 million per person, per the IRS).
Florida has no estate tax, per the Florida Department of Revenue. For many Chicago families, this line decides it. Keeping Illinois real estate after you move can keep some Illinois exposure, so have your estate attorney and your CPA review it.
Insurance, HOA and Club Fees
Insurance. This is where South Florida takes some back. The Florida Office of Insurance Regulation's July 2026 report shows average homeowners premiums with wind of $6,136 in Broward and $6,323 in Palm Beach (March 31, 2026), all home sizes, no flood. As I wrote in my South Florida insurance guide, a $1.7 million Intracoastal home in Boca ran about $7,000 a year and a $2.5 million home in Hollywood about $8,000, before flood. That guide also walks through wind, flood and the Citizens 2027 rule.
HOA and club fees. Plenty of east Fort Lauderdale and east Boca streets have no HOA. Gated communities add HOA dues, and equity clubs add initiation fees and annual dues. Those club numbers vary too widely, and change too often, to quote a single range here. If a club is in play, get the current initiation, dues and any special assessment in writing before you offer.
All-In Annual Carrying Cost: Illustrative $2M Home
Illustrative only. Not a tax estimate for any real property. Assumes a $2 million market/just value, a homesteaded primary residence bought in 2027 or later, $500,000 of Illinois net income, and no HOA. Uses 2026 Florida millage and the 2026 additional homestead exemption of $26,411. Rates: Cook County Clerk 2025 Chicago average, Broward and Palm Beach 2026 final millage. Talk to your CPA about your facts.
Annual line item | City of Chicago | Fort Lauderdale | Boca Raton |
|---|---|---|---|
Property tax | about $40,800 (6.853% avg rate, Homeowner Exemption) | about $36,000 (18.4026 mills, homestead) | about $33,100 (16.9090 mills, homestead) |
City fees on the tax bill | included in rate | about $895 (stormwater + fire, FY 2027) | varies, check the parcel |
State income tax on $500K | $24,750 (4.95%) | $0 | $0 |
Homeowners insurance | your current premium | about $7K-$8K wind (examples from our insurance guide) + flood | about $7K-$8K wind + flood |
HOA / club | $0 (no HOA) | $0 non-HOA; club communities extra | $0 non-HOA; club communities extra |
Subtotal before insurance | about $65,550 | about $36,900 | about $33,100 + fees |
Estate tax (one-time, not annual) | Illinois tax above $4M, not portable | none | none |
From the investor's side: before insurance, the gap is roughly $28,000 to $32,000 a year, mostly income tax. Subtract a Florida wind and flood bill that's likely higher than your Chicago premium, and you still keep real money. The estate line sits on top.
Say You Move $2 Million South
Say you sell a $2 million Chicago home and buy a $2 million house with no HOA, east of Federal in Fort Lauderdale, in 2027, and homestead it for 2028. Year-one property tax is in the same neighborhood, maybe a few thousand dollars lower. The $24,750 Illinois income tax goes away once your residency is real. Insurance runs higher, so hold cash for the hurricane deductible. And have your CPA review Illinois tax on any Chicago gain above the federal exclusion before you list.
Checklist Before You List in Chicago
- Pull your last two Cook County bills and your Assessor value
- Ask your CPA about Illinois tax on your gain, and about the residency switch
- Get Florida insurance quotes on the specific house before you offer
- Check flood zone, roof age and HOA or club costs
- Homestead: own and live there January 1, file by March 1
- Document the move: license, voter registration, declaration of domicile
- Estate attorney: review the $4 million Illinois exclusion and any Illinois property you keep
The steps in my New York domicile checklist mostly carry over. Illinois has its own residency rules, so confirm with your CPA.
What We're Seeing
The Chicago families I talk to aren't chasing the lowest tax bill. They want the income tax gone and no shoveling in February. The ones who do it well run the full carrying cost, including wind and flood, before they fall in love with a pool. If a dock is on the list, I'd start in Coral Ridge and the east Boca streets that actually fit $2 million, not the citywide median.
Quick Takeaways
- Year-one property tax on $2 million is similar: about $40,800 in Chicago versus $33,100 to $36,000 in Boca and Fort Lauderdale (illustrative).
- Illinois' 4.95% income tax is the biggest swing. Florida has none.
- Illinois estate tax starts above $4 million, not portable. Florida has none.
- Arriving in 2027 or later? Amendment 3's bigger exemption starts in year five.
- Talk to your CPA about the Chicago sale, Illinois residency and the Florida homestead calendar.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it cheaper to live in Fort Lauderdale or Boca than Chicago on a $2M home?
On carrying costs, usually yes, mainly because Florida has no state income tax. Year-one property taxes are similar, and insurance runs higher.
Are property taxes lower in Florida than in Cook County?
Not dramatically on a new purchase: about $36,000 in Fort Lauderdale and $33,100 in Boca versus $40,800 in Chicago on our illustrative $2 million homestead. Save Our Homes then caps homestead assessment increases at 3% or CPI.
Will Illinois tax the gain when I sell my Chicago home after I move?
It can. Gain on Illinois real estate above the federal exclusion may be taxed at 4.95% even after you move. Ask your CPA.
How does Amendment 3 affect me if I move from Chicago in 2027?
You start with the existing non-school homestead exemption and get the larger one from your fifth year of exemption, subject to any court challenge.
Does Florida have an estate tax?
No. Illinois taxes estates above a $4 million exclusion, not portable between spouses.
How much is homeowners insurance on a $2M home in South Florida?
It depends on the house. On the $1.7 million to $2.5 million examples in our insurance guide, wind policies ran about $7,000 to $8,000 a year before flood.
Bottom Line
Coming from Chicago, Florida doesn't win on the property tax rate. It wins on income tax, estate tax and a homestead cap that gets better every year you stay. Insurance can flip a good deal, so price it with the comps.
Comparing streets? Start with my Boca $1M-$5M neighborhood guide, then reach out to Johnny Madriz and The Madriz Team at SERHANT. We'll put taxes, insurance and HOA next to the comps before you write an offer. Call (954) 709-4432 or email [email protected].
The Chicago families who win here bought the carrying cost, not just the house.
Disclaimer: General information only, not tax, legal, insurance or financial advice. Rates, exemptions and premiums change and depend on the property and your facts. Review Illinois income and estate tax, residency and sale timing with a CPA and estate attorney, and Florida homestead questions with a Florida attorney or your county property appraiser. Table figures are illustrative.
Sources
- Illinois Department of Revenue, Income Tax Rates (individual 4.95%; accessed Nov. 12, 2026): https://tax.illinois.gov/research/taxrates/income.html
- Illinois Department of Revenue, 2025 IL-1040 Schedule NR Instructions (nonresident gain on Illinois real property; accessed Nov. 12, 2026): https://tax.illinois.gov/forms/incometax/currentyear/individual/il-1040-schedule-nr-instr.html
- Illinois Attorney General, Estate Taxes and Estate Tax Instruction Fact Sheet ($4,000,000 exclusion, non-portability, $5 million example; accessed Nov. 12, 2026): https://illinoisattorneygeneral.gov/estate-taxes/
- Cook County Clerk, 2025 Tax Rate Report (released Sept. 23, 2026; Chicago average 6.853%, Wilmette 6.357%, South and West suburban average 11.862%, 3.0300 equalizer, sample bill method; accessed Nov. 12, 2026): https://www.cookcountyclerkil.gov/publication/2025-tax-rate-report
- Broward County Property Appraiser, Millage Rates (2026 Fort Lauderdale 18.4026, code 0312; school 6.4527, non-school 11.9499; accessed Nov. 12, 2026): https://bcpa.net/millage.asp and 2026 Final Millage Rate Table: https://bcpa.net/Includes/Downloads/2026/2026%20Final%20Millage%20Rate%20Table.pdf
- City of Fort Lauderdale, Understanding Your Property Tax Notice (FY 2027 stormwater $451 and fire $444; accessed Nov. 12, 2026): https://www.fortlauderdale.gov/Government/Departments/Office-of-Management-and-Budget/Budget-CIP-and-Grants-Division/Understanding-Your-Property-Tax-Notice
- Palm Beach County Property Appraiser, 2026 Final vs Proposed Millage Rates (accessed Nov. 12, 2026): https://pbcpao.gov/pdf/taxroll/2026%20Final%20vs%20Proposed%20Millage%20Rates.pdf
- City of Boca Raton, 2026 Property Taxes Explained brochure (16.9090 total mills, 6.2870 school; accessed Nov. 12, 2026): https://www.myboca.us/DocumentCenter/View/44616/2026-Taxes-Explained-Brochure-Digital-PDF-
- Florida Department of Revenue, Property Tax Exemptions, additional homestead CPI adjustment ($26,411 for 2026), and PT-112 Save Our Homes guide (accessed Nov. 12, 2026): https://floridarevenue.com/property/Pages/Taxpayers_Exemptions.aspx and https://floridarevenue.com/property/Documents/cpi_homestead_exemption.pdf
- Florida Department of Revenue, personal income tax FAQ and Estate Tax page (accessed Nov. 12, 2026): https://www.floridarevenue.com/faq/Pages/FAQDetails.aspx?FAQID=1466 and https://floridarevenue.com/taxes/taxesfees/Pages/estate_tax.aspx
- IRS, What's New: Estate and Gift Tax (2026 basic exclusion $15,000,000; accessed Nov. 12, 2026): https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/whats-new-estate-and-gift-tax
- IRS, Topic No. 701, Sale of Your Home ($250,000 / $500,000 exclusion; accessed Nov. 12, 2026): https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc701
- Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, Property Insurance Stability Report, July 1, 2026 (county averages as of March 31, 2026; accessed Nov. 12, 2026): https://floir.gov/docs-sf/default-source/property-and-casualty/stability-unit-reports/july-2026-isu-report.pdf
- Illinois REALTORS, September 2026 market release and City of Chicago Local Market Update (Chicago all-property median $389,900; single-family median $375,000; accessed Nov. 12, 2026): https://www.illinoisrealtors.org/blog/illinois-home-prices-higher-in-september-home-sales-and-inventory-see-year-over-year-decline/ and https://www.illinoisrealtors.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/City-Sept2026.pdf
- MIAMI REALTORS + RWorld, Broward County City and Zip Code, September 2026 (Fort Lauderdale city single-family median $705,000; accessed Nov. 12, 2026): https://www.miamirealtors.com/wp-content/uploads/bsk-pdf-manager/2026/10/Broward-County-City-and-Zip-Code-September-2026.pdf
- MIAMI REALTORS + RWorld, Palm Beach County City and Zip Code, September 2026 (Boca Raton city single-family median $1,250,000; accessed Nov. 12, 2026): https://www.miamirealtors.com/wp-content/uploads/bsk-pdf-manager/2026/10/Palm-Beach-County-City-and-Zip-Code-September-2026.pdf
- MIAMI REALTORS + RWorld, South Florida Housing Market Report, September 2026 (million-dollar share: Palm Beach 29%, Broward 21%, under 10% nationally; accessed Nov. 12, 2026): https://www.miamirealtors.com/wp-content/uploads/bsk-pdf-manager/2026/10/South-Florida-Housing-Market-Report-September-2026.pdf
- Florida Realtors, Broward County Local Residential Market Metrics, Single-Family Homes by zip code, Q3 2026 (Coral Ridge-area zips 33305 and 33306; accessed Nov. 12, 2026): https://www.miamirealtors.com/wp-content/uploads/bsk-pdf-manager/2026/10/Zip_Broward-County_Single-Family-Homes_2026-Q3_Local-Residential-Market-Metrics.pdf
- Florida Division of Elections / Florida Election Watch, Amendment 3 certified results (Yes 4,922,977, No 3,020,085, 61.98%; certified by the Elections Canvassing Commission Nov. 17, 2026; accessed Nov. 18, 2026): https://floridaelectionwatch.gov/ContestResultsByCounty/900003